The Persistent Enchantment of the Myers-Briggs Character Check

The Myers-Briggs (MBTI) is among the most acknowledged persona assessments. Once I first took the take a look at a couple of yr in the past and was assigned INTJ or the “Architect”, a kind deemed “one of many rarest” and “most succesful,” it felt completely validating. My bluntness was the “knack for seeing by way of phoniness and hypocrisy” and my low need to foster friendships was merely a seek for an “mental match.” MBTI’s recognition spans quite a few books, podcasts, and web sites, and is commonly marketed as a viable instrument for profession exploration and workforce improvement. However a better take a look at the analysis is warranted.

MBTI advocates declare that by dividing folks into classes, the take a look at will help remove battle, enhance communication and teamwork, emphasis strengths, and encourage self-reflection. Derek Chapman, affiliate professor on the College of Calgary whose work contains analysis in industrial-organizational psychology, agrees that persona assessments in employment and hiring will be helpful, as they will help seize an individual’s “typical” means. However he cautions {that a} single persona take a look at won’t be helpful throughout all contexts.

someone right handed writing something down on a piece of paper

It’s value noting that even those that use the take a look at are sometimes conscious of its limitations. Shawn Bakker has written about using psychometric assessments within the office and explains that the MBTI was by no means designed to judge job candidates and shouldn’t be used to take action. This info, he says, has been clearly and persistently put out by the writer of the MBTI and distributors around the globe: “Makes use of of the MBTI in hiring are misplaced and never all that frequent, however after we are made conscious of it occurring in particular conditions, we attain out to these utilizing the instrument in error. The MBTI was designed to assist folks study their preferences, not their abilities.”

Bakker says that the MBTI strikes a superb steadiness between being complete whereas remaining pretty straightforward to make use of, which can account for its recognition. However Chapman warns that the MBTI was designed by individuals who weren’t skilled in psychometrics and its user-friendly nature ends in its use by many who usually are not correctly knowledgeable.

Chapman explains that we appear to be drawn to the take a look at for 2 primary causes: 1) it makes use of Barnum-effect statements, which sound as if they’re tailor-made to a selected individual however are as a substitute fairly basic, and a couple of) MBTI makes use of universally constructive statements and other people are inclined to relate strongly to constructive details about themselves, even when the knowledge is unverifiable or blatantly unfaithful.

a web of people

One other drawback lies within the assumption that the MBTI, a take a look at primarily based in Western theories of persona, can apply to folks worldwide. Overconfident use of the MBTI may end up in tales just like the one informed by Quinisha Jackson-Wright for The New York Instances, the place her expertise with the take a look at uncovered that MBTI screening was extra about cultural match than job {qualifications}. Additional, Chapman and others clarify that the take a look at has low test-retest reliability, which means outcomes are unstable and more likely to change for a person who takes the take a look at once more. To verify this myself, I took the MBTI once more months after my preliminary outcomes: I scored as INTP, modified from my prior kind as INTJ.

Nonetheless, the take a look at has its enchantment. Regardless of the analysis and consensus from the critics, there’s something very compelling about it. In my case, each my scores gave me cause to check myself favourably to somebody like Elon Musk, whose persona as per the MBTI sparked a Reddit debate over whether or not he’s an INTP or INTJ. Within the footsteps of Elon Musk?  Not too shabby.

– Jenna Zorik, Contributing Author

Picture Credit:
Function:  Tumisu
at Pixabay, Artistic Commons
First: GDJ
at Pixabay, Artistic Commons
Second: Unseen Studio 
at Unsplash, Artistic Commons


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.